Desi Truths
My Hometown vs. the City I Chose
I got off the local at Dadar tonight and for a second I forgot where I was. The crowd just pushed me along, I didn't even have to walk. My feet were moving but my brain was still stuck in that moment last Sunday when I was sitting on the chajja outside my room in the old house, watching the neem tree shed leaves into the gutter. Ammi had made aloo parathas and I didn't eat them. She gave me that look. The one that says "you think you're too big for this house now." And maybe I do. But also I don't. That's the whole problem.
So here's the thing yaar. I chose this city. Mumbai. I came here for a job that pays twelve thousand a month and a room that I share with two guys who snore in different rhythms. And every day I tell myself this is where things happen, this is where you grow, this is the real India. But then I go back home to that small town in UP for Diwali or Eid or whatever excuse I can make, and the moment the bus crosses the city limits I feel this weight lift off my chest. The air smells of cow dung and burning leaves and something that isn't diesel. The roads are empty enough that you can walk in the middle and not get honked at. Everyone knows everyone. The chaiwala at the bus stand knows I take two spoons of sugar without me even saying anything.
And that's when the guilt starts. Because in Mumbai I've become this person who judges that town. I roll my eyes when Ammi calls to ask if I'm eating properly. I tell my colleagues "oh my god my hometown has like zero café culture, nothing to do." I post Instagram stories of Marine Drive and pretend the struggle is glamorous. But deep down I know the hypocrisy. I judge the small town for its gossipy aunties and its lack of opportunities, but I also secretly crave that same gossipy intimacy. Here in Mumbai, nobody cares if you come home at 2 AM. But nobody cares if you're sick either. The landlady won't bring you kichdi. She'll just say "rent date ko yaad hai na?"
And the street intelligence thing. Man. I thought I was smart when I figured out how to navigate the Virar fast during peak hours. I thought I was a real city person when I learned to spot a pickpocket from a meter away. But then I went home last month and tried to bargain at the local vegetable market. The bhaiya looked at me and said "Mumbai se aa gaye? Ab rate nahi pata?" And he was right. I'd forgotten how to haggle. I'd forgotten the rhythm of that back-and-forth, the fake offended expressions, the "arey bhaiya itna mehnga?" I'd become too polite. Too soft. That's what the city does to you, makes you efficient but also makes you forget the raw street dance of survival that your hometown taught you.
But here's the other side. The chaotic beauty. When I'm standing on the Andheri footbridge at 8 PM and I see the sea of headlights below, and the sky is that hazy orange of streetlights mixing with exhaust, and there's a guy selling bhel puri on the corner who shouts at a taxi driver and the taxi driver shouts back and then they both laugh. That energy doesn't exist in my hometown. The silence there can be oppressive. Here the noise is almost like a blanket. You can't hear your own thoughts but maybe that's the point. Maybe I don't want to hear my own thoughts because they're all about Ammi and Abba and the empty chair at the dinner table.
I was at a party last week in Bandra. Some guy was talking about "curating experiences" and "mindful consumption" and I wanted to throw my drink at him. But I didn't. I nodded and smiled and thought about how in my hometown, we don't curate anything. We just live. We eat the same daal chawal every Tuesday. We watch the same saas-bahu serials. And we're happy. Or at least we pretend to be. Which is also a kind of hypocrisy, right? So maybe I'm just trading one hypocrisy for another.
Ammi called today. She said the neem tree fell down in the storm last week. "Ab tera favourite aam bhi nahi bachega," she said. And I felt this stupid lump in my throat. That tree was where I used to sit and read old Tinkle comics after school. I carved my initials into the bark when I was twelve. Now it's gone. And I'm here in a city where everyone is a stranger and even the trees have to be imported. She asked when I'm coming next. I said next month maybe. We both knew it's a lie. The job doesn't give that kind of leave. And honestly, the fare itself would eat up half my rent.
I don't know what I'm trying to say. Maybe nothing. Maybe I'm just tired. The fan is making that thak-thak sound again and my roommate has left the tap open in the bathroom. I should fix it but I won't. Tomorrow I'll wake up and do it all again. The train, the crowd, the fake smile at work. And I'll tell myself this city chose me as much as I chose it. But then at night, like this, when the noise dies down for five minutes, I hear the neem tree falling all over again.
Phone battery's at 6%. I think I'll just sleep without charging. Let it die. Let everything go silent for a bit.